Rahab

Justified by faith, then by works (James 2:14-26) – Part 7

POST OVERVIEW. The seventh and final post in a series of articles on James 2:14-26. The purpose of these articles is to give the believer a correct understanding of this passage by providing a number of different approaches to this text. The goal is that, through these studies, the believer will see that James’ teaching here does not conflict with the New Testament’s doctrine of justification by faith. (See also Post #652, 5/24,2023; Post #653, 5/25/2023; Post #654, 5/30/2023; Post #655, 6/5/2023; Post #658, 6/9/2023, Post #659 6/13/2023.)

We are in the midst of a deep dive into James 2:14-26. The reason we are going into considerable detail in studying this passage is that James 2 contains teaching about being “justified by works” that false teachers have used to claim that the Bible is unclear on justification. Because of this claim, the previous posts have taken a defensive position with regard to the passage, demonstrating from different vantage points that there is no contradiction between James’ teaching that the genuine believer is “justified” by his works and Paul’s teaching that the sinner is “justified” by placing his faith in Jesus Christ.

To make this point clear, we have presented five studies of James 2:14-26, each of which supported the premise that James and Paul are not at odds. Below is a summary of those studies.

  • In #653, we studied the key word “justify” and discovered that Paul uses the word in the sense of “declare righteous” and James uses the word in the sense of “prove a claim” or “validate a claim.” No conflict.
  • In #654, we examined the New Testament’s teaching on “works” and discovered that human “works” offered by the unsaved sinner to merit or earn salvation are an abomination to God, since they attempt to substitute sin-stained human “works” for the atoning death of Christ. But after salvation, the believer is expected to bear the fruit of good “works” (John 15:8; Eph. 2:10) as the result of their salvation. No conflict.
  • In #655, we reviewed the personal relationship that existed between Paul and James and saw that, in public doctrinal discussion (Acts 15 and Galatians 2), these two men were in complete agreement about the gospel. Thus it is inconceivable that James would write an epistle contradicting Paul’s primary doctrinal position about “justification by faith alone.” No conflict.
  • In #658, we presented the New Testament evidence supporting: 1) no one is justified (declared righteous) by his works; 2) genuine faith will produce good works; and 3) justification is by faith alone. The evidence overwhelmingly supports “No conflict.”
  • In #659, we compared the teaching in Hebrews 11 where “By faith” Abraham offered up Isaac and “By faith” Rahab protected the spies, with the teaching in James 2:21-25 about the identical events and discovered that these were believers giving evidence of their faith by “works” of obedience. No conflict.

Having successfully concluded our defense, we will now simply exegete these verses to give the plain meaning of the text. We will see that James’ entire argument requires that the person under consideration already professes faith in Jesus. James is writing to professing believers and he is asking the question, “Is the faith that you claim to possess a true saving faith?” Or, in other words, “How do you ‘justify’ your claim of saving faith?” The main point James is bringing home is that saving faith is “justified” by a life marked by good “works.”

AN EXEGESIS OF THE PASSAGE

  • 2:14-17 – James gives an example of faith without works. “What use is that (2:16)?” The expected answer is, “It’s not worth anything!” “Even so faith, if it has no works, is dead.” A works-less faith is dead, so without works of faith, your claim is not justified.
  • 2:18 – The problem of a mere claim of faith is that anyone can make such a claim. It may be real or it may be empty, but there is no way to tell based on the person’s claim alone. Ah, but show me your godly works, and show me your obedience, and show me your fruit in keeping with repentance, and I will believe you possess the faith you claim.
  • 2:19 – Being completely orthodox in your theology does not mean you are saved. James presents the example of the demons, who are perfectly orthodox in their theological beliefs. The demons know God is one, they know that Jesus is God in human flesh, and they know that He is going to judge them at the end of the age. But the demons have no “works” and so cannot “justify” a claim of faith. In the same way, if you have impeccable theology but no “works,” you also cannot “justify” a claim of faith.
  • 2:20 – For the third time (2:14, 17), James makes the point that a “works-less” faith is a useless faith. Only a fool would believe otherwise, because “faith without works is useless.”
  • 2:21-23 – Abraham proved the immensity of his faith by his “works,” by obediently offering up his beloved son Isaac as a sacrifice. The faith in God that had justified Abraham when his faith “was reckoned to him as righteousness” many years before (Genesis 15:6; James 2:23), was justified (proven, validated) and perfected when Abraham offered up Isaac on Moriah.
  • You see that Abraham was justified by faith (James 2:23), and then Abraham’s faith was justified by his works (2:21).
  • 2:24 – “You see that a man is justified (exonerated) by (the visible evidence of) “works” and not by (a claim of) faith alone.”
  • 2:25 – Even Rahab the harlot proved that she had saving faith by the “works” she did. She risked her life by sending the spies out by another way. Thus, her invisible saving faith was made visible. So, her claim of faith was justified by her works.
  • 2:26 – James concludes his argument, having proven that “Faith without works is dead.”

CONCLUSION. This important section in James gives a warning to those who make a claim of faith but whose life gives little or no evidence of the fruit of good works. Those who have been justified (declared righteous) by faith will be justified (confirmed, validated, exonerated) by good works.

It is faith alone that saves, but the faith that saves is not alone.

Soli Deo gloria            rmb                 6/16/2023                   #660

Justified by faith or by works? (James 2:14-26) – Part 6

POST OVERVIEW. The sixth in a series of articles on James 2:14-26. The purpose of these articles is to give the believer a correct understanding of this passage by providing a number of different approaches to this text. The goal is that, through these studies, the believer will see that James’ teaching here does not conflict with the New Testament’s doctrine of justification by faith. (See also Post #652, 5/24,2023; Post #653, 5/25/2023; Post #654, 5/30/2023; Post #655, 6/5/2023; Post #658, 6/9/2023.) This article will compare the teaching about Abraham and Rahab in Hebrews 11 with parallel teaching in James 2:21-25.

We are in the midst of a deep dive into James 2:14-26. The reason we are going into considerable detail in studying this passage is that James 2 contains teaching about being “justified by works” that appears to be in direct conflict with the teaching of Paul on justification by faith alone. False teachers and the Catholic church have capitalized on this apparent conflict and have insisted that our human “works” merit for us our salvation. Our goal in this series is to demonstrate from a variety of different angles that there is nothing in this passage in James 2 to suggest that our “works” contribute anything to our salvation. In other words, James is in complete agreement with the rest of the New Testament in declaring that justification (being declared righteous) is by faith alone, apart from works (of the Law).

REFERRING TO THE HALL OF FAME OF FAITH IN HEBREWS 11

This next study will refer to Hebrews 11, the “hall of fame of faith,” and compare what is said there about Abraham and Rahab with what James also says about Abraham and Rahab in James 2:21-25. From this investigation, we will discover, once again, that James is not teaching a new doctrine of salvation by works that conflicts with Paul’s gospel. But before we begin our investigation of these texts, we need to make some comments about Hebrews 11.

COMMENTS ON HEBREWS 11. Hebrews 11 is a chapter devoted to the “works” that selected Old Testament believers did which manifested their genuine faith. “By faith” is the English phrase that is repeated eighteen (18) times in the chapter. This phrase indicates that these Old Testament characters already possessed saving faith, because you cannot act “by faith” if you do not already possess faith. This means that all the characters in this chapter had already been “justified” (i.e., declared righteous) by faith before they performed their works of faith. Then, already possessing saving faith, these men and women took dramatic action (“works”) that both required saving faith and manifested saving faith. Thus we see that each one of the characters in Hebrews 11 was “justified by works” in the same sense that Abraham and Rahab were “justified by works” in James 2. Their radical obedience to the Lord provided visible evidence that they were already believers.

ABRAHAM. Now we will look specifically at Hebrews 11:17 about Abraham.

By faith Abraham, when he was tested, offered up Isaac, and he who had received the promises was offering up his only begotten son. – Hebrews 11:17

First, it is apparent that this verse is about Abraham’s sacrifice of Isaac on Mount Moriah from Genesis 22. Next, we observe that Abraham acted “by faith,” indicating that his sacrifice of Isaac was not done to merit his own salvation or to obtain righteousness from God, because he already possessed saving faith. Third, the Scripture says that Abraham was “tested.” God tested Abraham’s faith to determine its genuineness and its strength. And, because Abraham already had faith, he responded to the test with extreme obedience.

Having examined Hebrews 11:17 about Abraham, we now turn to the identical event described in James 2:21.

Was not Abraham our father justified by works when he offered up Isaac his son on the altar? – James 2:21

First, this is obviously about Abraham’s sacrifice of Isaac from Genesis 22. Second, we read that Abraham was “justified by works.” From our study of Hebrews 11:17, we know that, at the time of this sacrifice of Isaac, Abraham already possessed saving faith and had already been declared righteous by faith (confirm James 2:23 quoting Genesis 15:6). The obedient offering of Isaac (a “work”) “justified” Abraham in that it gave an astonishing display of the strong faith he possessed. So, in the case of Abraham, we see once again that “justified by works” has nothing to do with meriting salvation by human effort.

RAHAB. Our procedure for studying Rahab the harlot will be the same as for Abraham.

By faith Rahab the harlot did not perish along with those who were disobedient, after she had welcomed the spies in peace. – Hebrews 11:31

First, Rahab obviously acted “by faith,” indicating that she already possessed saving faith before the spies arrived. When we investigate the background of this verse from the book of Joshua, we see that, by the time “she had welcomed the spies in peace,” Rahab had already declared her allegiance to the LORD (Joshua 2:9-11) and she had identified with the people of God (Joshua 2:21). Clearly, she was a woman of faith before the spies arrived in Jericho. Finally, we note that Rahab “did not perish with those who were disobedient.” Significant here is that she was obedient and she lived.

Now we turn to James 2:25 and his verse about Rahab.

In the same way, was not Rahab the harlot also justified by works when she received the messengers and sent them out by another way? – James 2:25

“Rahab the harlot was also justified by works.” James is saying that, just as Abraham was justified by works, so also Rahab was justified by works. And how was Abraham justified by his “works?” His radical obedience (offering Isaac at the LORD’s command) “gave an astonishing display of his strong faith.” In the same way, Rahab’s courageous obedience in the face of dangerous consequences “gave an astonishing display of the strong faith that she possessed.” So, in this way, Rahab was “justified by works.”

CONCLUSION. A comparison of James 2:21 and 2:25 with parallel verses in Hebrews 11 has revealed, once again, that James is not teaching an errant doctrine of imputed righteousness by human works but is stating the biblical truth that genuine faith is “justified” by actions which display that faith.

Soli Deo gloria            rmb                 6/13/2023                   #659